Handyman vs Contractor: What’s the Real Difference (and Why Jay’s Handyman Services Does Both Better)
When it comes to improving your home, one of the most common questions homeowners ask is:
“Should I hire a handyman or a contractor?”
The truth is, both can handle repairs and renovations — but the right choice depends on the scope of the project and who you trust to get it done right.
At Jay’s Handyman Services, we combine the versatility of a handyman with the expertise of a contractor, giving homeowners the best of both worlds. Whether it’s a small repair, a full kitchen remodel, or fixture upgrades, our team has the skills and experience to handle it all.
Understanding the Difference Between a Handyman and a Contractor
A traditional handyman usually focuses on smaller repairs — things like fixing drywall, installing fixtures, or doing general maintenance.
A general contractor, on the other hand, typically manages large-scale projects that involve permits, multiple trades, or structural work.
However, Jay’s Handyman Services is not your typical handyman business.
We handle everything from minor fixes to full remodeling projects, including:
Kitchen and bathroom remodels
Additions and room conversions
Electrical and plumbing updates
Flooring, framing, drywall, and carpentry
Custom renovations and design builds
We also obtain permits when required and follow all building codes — offering the professionalism of a contractor, without the inflated overhead or corporate feel.
Permits and Professionalism
Some homeowners assume a handyman can’t handle major renovations — and in many cases, that’s true. But Jay’s Handyman Services operates differently.
We’re always obtaining the necessary permits when required and following Ohio’s building regulations.
That means you can have the confidence of hiring a contractor — without the stress, cost, or layers of middlemen.
When you call Jay’s, you deal directly with the people doing the work, not a subcontracted crew you’ve never met.
When You Should Hire a Handyman
A handyman is perfect for:
Minor home repairs
Routine maintenance
Small upgrades or installations
Fix-it lists before selling your home
These are the bread-and-butter services that keep your property looking great and functioning smoothly.
When You Should Hire a Contractor
You’d traditionally hire a contractor for:
Full remodels (kitchen, bath, basement)
Major plumbing or electrical upgrades
Additions or new construction
But here’s where Jay’s Handyman Services stands apart — we handle those same large projects, while offering a personalized, hands-on approach that big contracting companies can’t match.
Why Homeowners in Lake County Choose Jay’s Handyman Services
When you compare a typical handyman and a contractor, you often have to choose between affordability or expertise.
With Jay’s Handyman Services, you don’t have to choose — you get both.
Here’s why we’re the better option for nearly every type of project:
✅ Full-Service Capabilities: From minor fixes to full remodels — we do it all.
✅ Personalized Service: You deal directly with a local team that cares about your home.
✅ Affordable and Honest Pricing: Affordable with transparent pricing!
✅ Fast Scheduling: No months-long waitlists — we get the job done efficiently.
✅ Quality Craftsmanship: We take pride in every nail, tile, and finish.
You’ll get contractor-quality results with handyman-level care and value — all from one trusted local business.
The Bottom Line: Jay’s Handyman Services Gives You the Best of Both Worlds
If your project is big enough to need professional oversight but small enough that you don’t want to hire a full-blown construction firm — Jay’s Handyman Services is the perfect fit.
We bring the skillset of contractors and the reliability of handymen together under one roof, giving you a smoother, simpler, and more affordable experience from start to finish.
Get Started Today
Whether it’s a quick repair or a full remodel, Jay’s Handyman Services can handle the job — efficiently, affordably, and with pride in every detail.
🛠️ Serving Lake County, Ohio, and surrounding areas with professional home improvement, remodeling, and repair services.
Call today for your free estimate and see why homeowners across Lake County trust Jay’s Handyman Services to get the job done right.
Jay’s Handyman Services
Jayshandy.com
Jayshandyman@roadrunner.com
(440)478-5103
🔨 Reliable. Trustworthy. Family-Owned.
Because your home deserves the best.